Compared several LP cases, and, well, obviously the Gator case won :) It's rather light, easy to carry (well-balanced), and my Gibson LP Special (worn brown version) fits perfectly.
Haven't toured with it, but after a couple of gigs (and a lot of travelling between home & rehearsal room) it still looks as good as new, seems to be really solid! OK, the ABS surface is a little prone to scratches, but well, that's Rock'n'Roll ;) Yet, no real dents or damages, the hinges and locks also seem to be very reliable, much better than with any cases in the same price range (or even a little above).
The SKB case I compared was even better in quality, but if you aren't a touring pro, the Gator is absolutely OK, good quality, all you'll ever need - at a really competitive price, so I'd definitely chose the Gator Case again!